yceffort
◆ SERIES 3 POSTS

Judgment in the AI Era

Essays on what remains for developers when AI writes the code, examined through the lens of judgment and responsibility

README

There is no shortage of writing about the era of AI writing code. Much of it, though, is about how much productivity has gone up, and it sidesteps the question of what is actually left for developers. This series is a set of essays that takes that question head on.

Each part looks at one angle: whether it really doesn't matter that you can't read code as long as the spec is satisfied, what actually collapses and what survives when the boundaries between roles blur, and why the ability that becomes most expensive is the one that gets trained the least. To state the conclusion that runs through all three up front: production moves, but judgment and responsibility do not.

These are essays, not technical deep dives, so there are no measurements. Instead, each argument states the premises it relies on in the text, so if you disagree with something, it is worth starting with those premises.

03 ITEMS

All posts

in order
01

If the Code Meets Spec and the Bugs Get Fixed, Does It Matter That You Can't Read It?

#ai#essay#career
If the spec is satisfied and the bugs get fixed, do you still need to be able to read the code? This essay weighs the argument that you do not and the weak points in its premises, then lays out what you need to understand when you stop reading code directly and what juniors should aim for.
21 min read
02

If AI Erases the Boundaries Between Planning, Development, and Design, What Remains?

#ai#essay#software-engineering
With AI tools, people can now produce the deliverables of other roles, and so we hear that the boundaries between job titles are collapsing. Separate the ability to make something from the ability to know whether it is right, and where do the boundaries get redrawn?
Updated
20 min read
03

When Was the Last Time You Read Code Seriously?

#essay#ai#career
As code review and interviews stop reading code closely, there are fewer chances to build the judgment that matters more in the AI era. This essay checks the evidence from studies such as METR and GitClear, and considers why the need to learn judgment went away.
Updated
13 min read